Suzanna Noort
31Aug/082

iGoogle Experiment

I am one of the chosen few! Chosen as a beta-tester for Google's new version of their iGoogle personalized homepage. However, after my initial feeling of pride at being part of a select few (a pride that conveniently forgot that the selection was most probably made at extreme random by a computer) I have decided I want the old version back. This one is annoying, buggy and space-consuming.

As I can't opt out of this damn experiment, I can no longer make a screenshot of the old version to compare, but the new one looks like this (click on the image for a larger view).

They have moved the page tabs to the left instead of horizontally along the top. This takes up loads of space and I barely used the tabs anyway. The GMail widget doesn't work properly (you'd expect a Google product to have been tested better): you can read individual e-mails but all HTML links are dead in them and you can't even reply to a mail - duh!

Another space issues is that the RSS widgets now show the title plus 2 lines of the post itself. You cannot alter this and it means there's a lot less overview without scrolling. In the old version, if you hover over the title of a post it'll actually pop-up the complete article (unformatted) which was kinda handy.

So basically, get me back to the old one please!! (And I'm not the only one that feels this way: as can be read on the Google discussion groups - not that Google ever seems to take any notice).

It has surprised me how unintuitive a lot of Google's so-called "improvements" are. The new version of GMail (already almost a year old, I think) has a HORRIBLE contact interface for example. If I ever need to make a group I temporarily revert back to the old version of GMail as it's really annoying in the new version.

Comments (2) Trackbacks (0)
  1. Oh poor darling! That’s what you get when you are chosen by Google. Now you can imagine what it feels like when you are chosen by God ;-)

  2. The thing is that I’d probably like this layout on the big high resolution screen that’s attached to my main work PC. On my netbook’s 1024*600 screen however it would probably been unusable. So I hope Google has added a way to choose the layout per machine, in a persistent way.


Leave a comment


Trackbacks are disabled.